Former Johannesburg mayor and ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba has contradicted Helen Zille’s claims that Julius Malema instructed him to appoint former police general Shadrack Sibiya to head the city’s anti-corruption unit.
In a sworn affidavit filed in support of Malema’s legal application against Zille, Mashaba says it was Zille who recommended that he seek advice from former prosecutor Glynnis Breytenbach on a suitable candidate for the position.
The affidavit, dated 16 November 2026, forms part of Malema’s court proceedings against Zille over allegations that the EFF leader influenced municipal decisions and appointments during Mashaba’s tenure as Johannesburg mayor.
Zille had alleged during an eNCA interview that Mashaba appointed Sibiya on Malema’s instructions as part of an arrangement to secure the EFF’s political support.
She claimed that Malema dictated major decisions in the municipality, influenced the City Power fleet tender and used Mashaba’s administration to advance his interests.
However, Mashaba disputes this version.
According to his affidavit, he did not know Sibiya before the recruitment process began and had no prior relationship with him.
Mashaba says the process started after the position in the City’s Group Forensic and Investigation Service became vacant. He says his then chief of staff, Michael Beaumont, approached Zille for advice on possible candidates.
Zille allegedly recommended that Beaumont approach Breytenbach, who subsequently identified Sibiya as a potential candidate because of his law enforcement experience.
Beaumont has also filed an affidavit corroborating Mashaba’s account. He says he approached Zille for guidance and was directed to Breytenbach.
Sibiya was subsequently encouraged to apply for the advertised position and went through the city’s recruitment process before being appointed.
Mashaba also denies that Malema ever instructed him on municipal procurement decisions or discussed the awarding of tenders with him.
“At no stage during my tenure as Mayor did I have any conversation with Mr Malema regarding the award, allocation, or determination of municipal tenders within the City,” Mashaba states in his affidavit.
He further rejects Zille’s suggestion that he allowed municipal processes to be manipulated for Malema’s personal benefit in exchange for the EFF’s political support.
The affidavit directly challenges Zille’s account of Sibiya’s appointment, placing her alleged recommendation at the centre of the dispute.
Malema is seeking an interdict preventing Zille from repeating the allegations while pursuing a defamation claim against her. Zille has indicated that she intends to oppose the application.
The matter is unfolding amid ongoing coalition negotiations in Johannesburg, where Zille and Mashaba are at the centre of discussions over the city’s future leadership.












